Appointment television viewing may not be dead after all if there’s live content being produced that’s compelling enough — and if it’s available to where the user is. In any case, it seems that YouTube TV and Hulu with Live TV have garnered some appeal, earning a combined 750,000 subscribers in the first several months of operations.

More specifically, Google’s product, which has been out since April and has recently expanded to 80 local TV markets, has been recorded with just over 300,000 subscribers. Hulu, owned by a consortium of the major US broadcast networks, has 450,000 non-promotional subscribers to its Live TV plan which began in May. Both figures are not public, but were given to CNBC from sources.

For comparison, AT&T’s DIRECTV NOW recently reported subscribership of 1 million while Dish Network’s Sling box has an estimated presence in more than 2 million households.

Analysts, like BTIG’s Rich Greenfield, say that web-based services will have trouble competing with the sheer content that Netflix and Amazon Prime Video are putting out and will have higher cancellation rates than services linked up with traditional providers such as DIRECTV and Dish just because the process takes “four clicks.”

“If you don’t care about live sports, the original Hulu product is awesome. You can get all of the programming you want for more than $30 less,” Greenfield told CNBC. “And YouTube is free. It actually shows you how poor the value proportion is for live TV.”

YouTube TV costs $35 per month while Hulu with Live TV is $39.99 monthly.

You May Also Like
Huawei Mate 30 Pro review

Huawei Mate 30 Pro review: the best phone you can’t get, and that’s OK

In our Huawei Mate 30 Pro review we’re trying to answer the question of whether the phone can survive without Google support, and should you buy it?

Companies could soon get licenses to sell to Huawei

Good news for Huawei: In a recent Bloomberg interview, Commerce Secretary W. Ross said he was optimistic about reaching a “Phase One” China deal this month.

The upcoming Moto Razr has been spotted in the wild, with a huge chin

It seems that the new Moto Razr is already being caught in the wild, with a huge chin, and there’s a picture to prove it