In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court has ruled that law enforcement will need a search warrant to obtain a citizen’s cellphone location data. Chief Justice John Roberts swung with the court’s four liberal-leaning justices for the prevailing opinion while the four conservative justices, in a rare move, each wrote dissents.

Up until now, such data could obtained by police and other agencies as long as it was assured that it is relevant evidence to building a case against the suspected. However, this decision gives the search Fourth Amendment privacy protections and would require “probably cause” for prosecuting parties to achieve a warrant.

Citizens generally give up their Fourth Amendment protection if they contribute items and information to a third party. In this particular case, Timothy Carpenter was being tried for armed robbery and the police implicated his involvement based on location data obtained by Carpenter’s wireless carrier. His lawyers argued that since the data was not obtained through a warrant that it was not admissible as evidence.

In his opinion, Chief Justice Roberts says the ruling will be applied narrowly to historical records perhaps at least 7 days old and that no opinion has been made on real-time record collecting. SCOTUSblog reports that Roberts also made allowances for warrantless collections to be made in emergency situations such as “bomb threats, active shootings, and child abductions.” That said, this does not mean that the government has “unrestricted access” of location data from networks.

Dissenting opinions generally were against the restriction of the government’s ability to enforce law and claim that the decision is a protective facade of citizens’ privacy rights.

You May Also Like

Verizon customers are getting more TV and learning options for free

More freebies are coming to Verizon Wireless customers, as well as Fios TV customers that will receive more channels and learning content for free

Apple may also lauch new HomePod, iMac, and iPads in 2020

We may get more Apple devices than the ones we were expecting since a new report mentions the possibility of a new HomePod and iPad for 2020

Vivo Y50 with quad rear cameras and punch hole display goes official for $249

Vivo Y50 employs the octa-core Qualcomm Snapdragon 665 SoC and packs a large 5,000mAh battery under the hood, complete with 18W fast charging support.